Steven Cheslik-DeMeyer

Steven Cheslik-DeMeyer

  • Blog
  • About
  • Work
  • Contact

I took this photo on my first trip to New York, Thanksgiving 1979.

The Fantasticks.

November 19, 2026 by Steven Cheslik-DeMeyer

The first time I saw The Fantasticks was a student production my freshman year at Miami University, and I remember being thrilled mostly because its stripped down and self-conscious theatricality was exotic and experimental to my 18-year-old eyes. Later that fall, on my first trip to New York, I saw the original production in the Village. I remember it a little gauzily — it’s hard to tease out specific memories of the show from the I can hardly breathe I can’t believe I am finally here feeling of an Indiana gay boy’s first sight of Greenwich Village, Mecca, Oz — but I must have loved it, because I bought the cast album and listened to it a lot during those years. It made me cry back then and apparently it still does. My face was totally wet by the final curtain last night.

The show shares some DNA with Our Town — and has the same perception problem of that show, that, because it’s so simple, people will sometimes miss how deep it is. Sondheim famously said The Fantasticks was “the definition of twee.” Sondheim said a lot of things. But then he borrowed its conceit wholesale for Into the Woods. Personally, I think Sondheim could have learned a thing or two from The Fantasticks about letting one’s guard down, but maybe that’s just me. The show’s influence on Stephen Schwartz is pretty clear, too, especially in the 70s shows like Pippin and Godspell.

I suppose there are things I could quibble about. I wanted El Gallo to be darker, a little scary, less dorky muscle boy, and his costume was terrible, but when he sang I was disarmed. Maybe the show suffers a bit on a larger stage, but only maybe, and what a lovely stage. The set design and especially the lighting were pure, distilled theater magic. The new orchestration sounds great and it’s perfect for the room, but I’ll admit at times I missed the directness of the piano and harp.

In the end though it’s the boys’ open-hearted, completely unironic performances that make it all work. Their songs are so gentle, and their singing so tender, that I found myself leaning in, which is my favorite thing to do. 

November 19, 2026 /Steven Cheslik-DeMeyer
  • Newer
  • Older

Powered by Squarespace